YOUNGSTOWN — Deputies Friday arrested the man who claimed he acted in self defense when he shot and killed his wife’s lover and critically injured his wife in what he said was an accident.
Deputies were called to the home of Michael and Susan McCoy on Rhonda Road early Wednesday morning after Michael McCoy called 911 to report that he had shot his wife and David Walker after he learned she had been having an affair with Walker, who was shot multiple times and pronounced dead at the scene.
Susan McCoy, 37, was taken to a hospital for treatment. She was in “guarded condition” Friday, according to the Bay County Sheriff’s Office.
Michael McCoy told investigators following the shooting that he initially armed himself with the intention of taking his own life, but his wife talked him out of it. He said he demanded Walker — who apparently had been staying with the couple since he was released from the Bay County Jail on Sunday following a domestic battery arrest — leave their home. The two men began to argue before he shot Walker.
Because there were no other witnesses to the shooting, which occurred around 2:30 a.m. in the front yard of the McCoys’ home, investigators were waiting for Susan McCoy to recover to the point where they could take her statement. Whether he was charged or not would depend on whether her version of the shooting confirmed what Michael McCoy said.
Investigators spoke with Susan McCoy Friday. BCSO officials didn’t release any details from her statement, and they didn’t return a call for comment Friday, but Michael McCoy was arrested shortly afterwards. He is charged with an open count of murder and attempted murder. He was taken to the Bay County Jail to await his first court appearance Saturday.
An earlier version of this story is posted below:
YOUNGSTOWN -- A Bay County man who fatally shot another man and injured his wife was arrested today, the Bay County Sheriff’s Office announced.Deputies were called the home of Michael and Susan McCoy early Wednesday morning after Michael McCoy called 911 to report that he had shot his wife and David Walker after he learned she had been having an affair with Walker, who was shot multiple times and pronounced dead at the scene.
Susan McCoy, 37, was taken to a hospital for treatment. She was in “guarded condition” Friday, according to the Bay County Sheriff’s Office.
Michael McCoy told investigators following the shooting that he initially armed himself with the intention of taking his own life, but his wife talked him out of it. He said he demanded Walker — who apparently had been staying with the couple since he was released from the Bay County Jail on Sunday following a domestic battery arrest — leave their home. The two men began to argue before he shot Walker.
Because there were no other witnesses to the shooting, which occurred around 2:30 a.m. in the front yard of the McCoys’ home, investigators were waiting for Susan McCoy to recover to the point where they could take her statement. Whether he was charged or not would depend on whether her version of the shooting confirmed what Michael McCoy said.
Investigators spoke with Susan McCoy Friday. BCSO officials didn’t release any details from her statement, and they didn’t return a call for comment Friday, but Michael McCoy was arrested shortly afterwards. He is charged with an open count of murder and attempted murder. He was taken to the Bay County Jail to await his first court appearance Saturday.
An earlier version of this story is posted below:
YOUNGSTOWN -- A Bay County man who fatally shot another man and injured his wife was arrested Friday, the Bay County Sheriff’s Office announced this afternoon.
Michael McCoy was charged with murder in the two shootings at his home at 8505 Rhonda Road on Wednesday.
David Walker, 47, was shot multiple times and died at the scene. McCoy’s wife, Susan McCoy, was shot and is in a local hospital in guarded condition.
Michael McCoy called 911 after the shooting and waited for deputies to arrive. He was detained and gave a statement to BCSO criminal investigators about the incident. McCoy said he had just learned that evening that Walker and his wife were having an affair. McCoy, who suffers from physical disabilities and has difficulty walking, stated he shot Walker in self defense during a verbal altercation outside the home. McCoy said that his wife was shot accidentally while trying to prevent the incident.